I once gave some 11th graders what I thought
would be an interesting assignment; read
an article about Somali pirates and compare it to the entry on Caribbean
pirates from their textbook. When the essays came back, most of them were
gobble-de-gook. Sentences began with the word “and,” things that should have
been used as a conclusion were in the middle, and sentences were written on top
of each other because the student “forgot” and had to jam them in. This was an
inner-city school, and while the kids were not without intelligence, they were seriously
lacking in any kind of writing skill.
The Power In Your
Hands give step-by-step instructions on how to teach kids to write. One of
the biggest problems with high school writing is that the kids’ essays are
usually all over the place, and as most teachers will agree, they have trouble
putting their thoughts together coherently. This book stresses formats for
essays, book reports, and other writings for kids.
The chapter Persuasion is about opinion v fact. The author
tries to explain it as a kid who tries to get his friends to eat pizza instead
of hamburgers. She starts with the “main idea” and proceeds to meatier ways to build and essay. For
bigger assignments, there’s brainstorming, research, creating the intro, and adjusting
the body paragraphs. The section on proofreading marks might be a little too
much for high schoolers, however. But the last chapter on expository writing is
important for most grades. Comparisons and metaphors are covered extensively,
and one cannot understress their importance if the students has any desire to
prove his or her opinion in their writing.
If your students have any intention of going to a four year
college, they’d better be able to write. If the assignment is “compare your
family Thanksgiving dinner to the Texas Chainsaw Massacre,” then they’d better
be able to write it coherently. The professor won’t give a damn if a 19 year
old never learned to write, it’s not his problem. If your kid has an opinion,
great, but if he/she can’t put it to paper, then college is not going to go
well.
No comments:
Post a Comment